How does a fixed pension rate work in combination with a salary reduction at the workplace?

I try to plan for what can happen. I always like to do some preliminary calculations so that if there is a change, I can quickly make plans to adjust, in this case, my pension contributions.

If Labour were to introduce a flat tax credit for pensions, how would that work for me? After all, my pension is paid out of my pre-tax salary.

I can get my head around 30% as a fixed rate if I invested in a self-invested personal pension (Sipp). But how would this work as a gross payment and what tax would be left to pay on my salary?

I currently put £60,000 a year into my pension. The new higher cap has really helped me catch up, as I have neglected my pension for years.

Tanya Jefferies from This is Money responds: The Labour Party has so far given no indication that there are plans to reform pension tax benefits.

However, it plans to conduct a ‘pensions landscape review’ to determine what steps are needed to improve pension outcomes and increase investment in UK markets.

This has led to speculation that the feasibility of radical reforms to the pension tax cut will also be examined.

With pension tax deduction, you actually get back all the tax you would have paid on your contributions, so that you are back to the old level.

This important addition to the pension pot is based on income tax rates of 20 percent, 40 percent or 45 percent. This makes the system more favorable for the better off, because they pay more tax.

Click here to resize this module

Changes would cause problems with final salary and other defined benefit pension schemes, and would conflict with salary reduction contributions.

Other disadvantages, already highlighted by commentators in the press, include the potential impact on the pensions of six million high-income earners, the impact on economic growth if they were to invest less as a result, and serious complications with public sector pensions, which could even trigger a new wave of strikes.

We asked a financial expert to explain how a flat tax rate on pensions would work for everyone and what pension savers can do to prepare for such a reform.

Ian Cook, accredited financial planner at Quilter Cheviot, answers: The possibility of a flat-rate pension deduction is a complex subject and its implementation would be even more complex.

It is important to note that making decisions based on speculation is not advisable. It is always best to plan your finances based on the current rules and your specific financial situation rather than ‘ifs and maybes’.

However, I will highlight some points that you should keep in mind as you think about this.

What is a flat-rate pension tax deduction?

With a fixed pension rate, everyone gets the same percentage tax deduction on their pension contributions, regardless of income tax bracket.

For example, if a flat rate of 30 percent were introduced, all pension contributions would receive this level of tax relief. In the current system, tax relief depends on your marginal tax rate (20 percent, 40 percent or 45 percent).

This would fundamentally change the way tax breaks are applied to pension savings and as such would require a massive, wholesale change to the pension tax landscape.

How does salary sacrifice work?

Salary sacrifice is a popular arrangement where you agree to a salary reduction in exchange for an equivalent pension contribution from your employer.

This is fiscally beneficial because it reduces your taxable income and you therefore pay less income tax and national insurance.

What is the impact of a flat-rate tax reduction on salary reduction?

This is how it could work with a fixed rate system.

If you currently pay £60,000 of your salary into your pension, that entire amount will be contributed pre-tax.

As a taxpayer in the higher rate, you effectively receive a 40 percent tax reduction on these contributions.

If a flat rate of 30 percent is introduced, the salary sacrifice mechanisms will have to be adjusted.

Under the new system, your £60,000 contribution will still reduce your taxable income, but the tax relief you get may vary depending on the implementation details.

For the flat-rate compensation to work, all pension contributions, including those of the employer, would have to be standardised.

This may require substantial changes to the current system, where contributions are deducted before tax.

While it is understandable that a new government will set the rumour mill in motion and changes to the pension landscape can be worrying, such rumours should not be entertained.

For example, employers must adjust their payroll administration to ensure that the correct amount of tax relief is applied.

If the fixed tax deduction is introduced, your contributions will still be paid before tax. However, the amount of tax deduction you receive may be recalculated based on the new fixed tax deduction.

How much time do savers have to plan ahead?

Given the complexity of such changes, it is likely that a significant period of consultation and phased implementation will be required, possibly spread over a period of years rather than weeks or months.

This gives you time to adjust your financial planning accordingly.

While it is wise to be aware of potential changes, it is never wise to make hasty decisions without being aware of the details.

I advise you to continue paying pension contributions under the current rules for the time being, as pensions are still a very tax-efficient way to save for your retirement.

As you indicate, you are making good use of the amended rules for the annual allowance to catch up on years of missed pension contributions. You would be wise to simply play with the policy conditions that you get at a given time.

Furthermore, it is important to realise that any major changes to pension tax relief are likely to be accompanied by transitional measures, so that individuals and employers have sufficient time to adapt.

For example, provisions could be included to exempt existing contributions under the old rules or to phase in new rules to limit the immediate financial impact.

By basing your planning on current regulations and seeking professional advice, you will be prepared for any future changes.

How should savers deal with the rumour mill about Labour’s pension changes?

While it is understandable that a new government will set the rumour mill in motion and that changes to the pension landscape can be worrying, no action should be taken on such rumours.

Major changes would be accompanied by ample notice and transitional measures.

By staying well informed, seeking personal advice and basing your planning on the current rules, you will be well prepared for any changes in pension tax.